Heitmiller Steakhouse

Went on a Wednesday for my husband birthday for the first time! It started off on a sour note in my book as I usually bring balloons to birthday dinners, but they don't allow ballons due to their tall ceilings even if I was to tie the balloons to the back of the chair. So I took them back to my vehicle. I tried to stay positive throughout the dinner. Our server was Mason, he was new, but he did great! He went above and beyond our entire visit. When the food came it was DELICIOUS! We were very impressed from the appetizers to dessert. A key plus was when the rolls came out it automatically came with cinnimon butter, which we love. We will for sure be back sooner than later! I would advise the restuarant to update their pictures of their menu on the website as the prices are different. I noticed this as my husband had ordered Cheesecake and the menu picture online says 4.99 but the receipt said 6.99. I would advise having someone to update that as it is kind of like false advertisement.

Went on a Wednesday for my husband birthday for the first time! It started off on a sour note in my book as I usually bring balloons to birthday dinners, but they don't allow ballons due to their tall ceilings even if I was to tie the balloons to the back of the chair. So I took them back to my vehicle. I tried to stay positive throughout the dinner. Our server was Mason, he was new, but he did great! He went above and beyond our entire visit. When the food came it was DELICIOUS! We were very impressed from the appetizers to dessert. A key plus was when the rolls came out it automatically came with cinnimon butter, which we love. We will for sure be back sooner than later! I would advise the restuarant to update their pictures of their menu on the website as the prices are different. I noticed this as my husband had ordered Cheesecake and the menu picture online says 4.99 but the receipt said 6.99. I would advise having someone to update that as it is kind of like false advertisement.

Now this is from 1 visit. I don’t usually give 5 stars, but just wow! We started with the stuffed mushrooms, which were delicious. The service was great, the food was even better. Fantastic atmosphere, so cool inside. I had the shaved Ribeye sandwich, so good! Meat was so tender topped with onions, peppers and mozzarella cheese. Our waitress gave me an Au jus sauce that was wonderful. My wife had Cajun grill tilapia with broccoli and sweat potato. Rolls and the cinnamon butter…..very good.

Now this is from 1 visit. I don’t usually give 5 stars, but just wow! We started with the stuffed mushrooms, which were delicious. The service was great, the food was even better. Fantastic atmosphere, so cool inside. I had the shaved Ribeye sandwich, so good! Meat was so tender topped with onions, peppers and mozzarella cheese. Our waitress gave me an Au jus sauce that was wonderful. My wife had Cajun grill tilapia with broccoli and sweat potato. Rolls and the cinnamon butter…..very good.

Very prompt seating for Sunday afternoon. Wait staff attentive. Patience, our waitress, was exceptional. She was courteous and checked on us frequently. Delivered our meals with accuracy and made recommendations that met our pallets. She let us know about the in house prepared desserts, bread and dressings. We enjoyed the delicious appitizer's of potatoes wedges, cheese sticks and guacamole and chips. Steaks cooked perfectly and seasoned well. The cinnamon butter and warm fresh bread complements the meal. Don't forget the in house made pies. Will eat here again.

Very prompt seating for Sunday afternoon. Wait staff attentive. Patience, our waitress, was exceptional. She was courteous and checked on us frequently. Delivered our meals with accuracy and made recommendations that met our pallets. She let us know about the in house prepared desserts, bread and dressings. We enjoyed the delicious appitizer's of potatoes wedges, cheese sticks and guacamole and chips. Steaks cooked perfectly and seasoned well. The cinnamon butter and warm fresh bread complements the meal. Don't forget the in house made pies. Will eat here again.

I want to like this place but every time we come here they make it harder to. The wait staff usually is pretty solid. It seems they can’t ever manage to cook a steak right. Medium rare means 5 seconds and flip on each side so it’s super rare. Luckily I don’t mind that. Each time someone orders well done it always has to go back to get cooked right.

I want to like this place but every time we come here they make it harder to. The wait staff usually is pretty solid. It seems they can’t ever manage to cook a steak right. Medium rare means 5 seconds and flip on each side so it’s super rare. Luckily I don’t mind that. Each time someone orders well done it always has to go back to get cooked right.

I ordered the bone in sirloin expecting it to be one of the best steaks I've ever had but it wasn't. I needed steak sauce to get a good taste to the steak. They don't add gravy to the mashed potatoes and there wasn't much taste to those either. It was honestly a disappointing experience.

I ordered the bone in sirloin expecting it to be one of the best steaks I've ever had but it wasn't. I needed steak sauce to get a good taste to the steak. They don't add gravy to the mashed potatoes and there wasn't much taste to those either. It was honestly a disappointing experience.

An absolutely amazing dinner. The steak was perfect and did not require any sauce. Covered in sautéed mushrooms and onions and butter. The grilled salmon on spinach with asparagus was perfect. The waiter was amazing as well. If you eat as kosher as possible in Texas. The stuffed mushrooms have bacon in them. They tasted good but there was something different we tasted and it was bacon. The manager removed the mushrooms from our bill. An amazing restaurant. It will be my go to place to eat when I am in Waco.

An absolutely amazing dinner. The steak was perfect and did not require any sauce. Covered in sautéed mushrooms and onions and butter. The grilled salmon on spinach with asparagus was perfect. The waiter was amazing as well. If you eat as kosher as possible in Texas. The stuffed mushrooms have bacon in them. They tasted good but there was something different we tasted and it was bacon. The manager removed the mushrooms from our bill. An amazing restaurant. It will be my go to place to eat when I am in Waco.

Awesome place!!! I’ve been going to Heitmiller’s for 30 years (the old one was in Elm Mott, Texas but shut down due to IH 35 expansion). I got the Steak K-Bob with mushrooms and it was great and cooked the way I wanted it. I’m doing the Keto diet and they helped me make the right choices. Staff is friendly and they hustle to make sure you get the best outta the place. Multiple menu items and the just don’t have steak. My wife got the Chicken Fried Steak and there was enough for two!!!! Great place that brings back memories.

Awesome place!!! I’ve been going to Heitmiller’s for 30 years (the old one was in Elm Mott, Texas but shut down due to IH 35 expansion). I got the Steak K-Bob with mushrooms and it was great and cooked the way I wanted it. I’m doing the Keto diet and they helped me make the right choices. Staff is friendly and they hustle to make sure you get the best outta the place. Multiple menu items and the just don’t have steak. My wife got the Chicken Fried Steak and there was enough for two!!!! Great place that brings back memories.

First and foremost if you are looking for good damn steak this place rocks. We got a prime rib and a bone in ribeye. Get the sweet potato fries, a salad and call it a day. You can skip the rolls and pick up some at Walmart where you can get real butter. I'm not sure what they are using for butter but it's tasteless and doesn't work. The baked potato, rolls, or anything that depends on good butter were a miss. Food, however, was cooked to perfect and delicious. The atmosphere was amazing from the Lonesome Dove mural to the expert taxidermy and the architectural wood elements were fantastic. The restaurant is laid out very well and serves its customers in style. The staff left me a little confused, most servers were wearing Crocs? And some had ball caps on. The service was fantastic and it wasn't enough to drop a star but it was odd. In summary, basically bring your own butter and don't let them use theirs.

First and foremost if you are looking for good damn steak this place rocks. We got a prime rib and a bone in ribeye. Get the sweet potato fries, a salad and call it a day. You can skip the rolls and pick up some at Walmart where you can get real butter. I'm not sure what they are using for butter but it's tasteless and doesn't work. The baked potato, rolls, or anything that depends on good butter were a miss. Food, however, was cooked to perfect and delicious. The atmosphere was amazing from the Lonesome Dove mural to the expert taxidermy and the architectural wood elements were fantastic. The restaurant is laid out very well and serves its customers in style. The staff left me a little confused, most servers were wearing Crocs? And some had ball caps on. The service was fantastic and it wasn't enough to drop a star but it was odd. In summary, basically bring your own butter and don't let them use theirs.