Treasure Island Supper Club

I based this on my top five. Food, service, drinks, atmosphere, and cleanliness. Food got a 3, wife's steak was over cooked and the potato boat(which was highly recommended) was horrible. It was very dry like it was in the salamander for a while. My recommendations for the steaks are not to get any of the seasoning or butters that they put on it. Steaks are great. A prime cuts of steak and do not need any of that stuff. In fact, my wife got the seasoning and didn't like it too much. Mine was perfect. Drinks got a 5, The bartender recommended a margarita for my wife and I got a captain and ginger ale. The atmosphere and cleanliness got a five, this was a very nice place. Comfy does not look run down. They maintain this facility to a high standard of cleanliness. Service was a 4. Bartender was very welcoming while we were waiting for our table. Made lots of recommendations. The server was very knowledgeable. A little slow on the tentativeness because of how busy they were and it took a little while to get our check. I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant. There are reasons why this has been an operation for such a long time.

I based this on my top five. Food, service, drinks, atmosphere, and cleanliness. Food got a 3, wife's steak was over cooked and the potato boat(which was highly recommended) was horrible. It was very dry like it was in the salamander for a while. My recommendations for the steaks are not to get any of the seasoning or butters that they put on it. Steaks are great. A prime cuts of steak and do not need any of that stuff. In fact, my wife got the seasoning and didn't like it too much. Mine was perfect. Drinks got a 5, The bartender recommended a margarita for my wife and I got a captain and ginger ale. The atmosphere and cleanliness got a five, this was a very nice place. Comfy does not look run down. They maintain this facility to a high standard of cleanliness. Service was a 4. Bartender was very welcoming while we were waiting for our table. Made lots of recommendations. The server was very knowledgeable. A little slow on the tentativeness because of how busy they were and it took a little while to get our check. I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant. There are reasons why this has been an operation for such a long time.

I have lived in this area for 30 years and have never been here. I finally went to dinner here and let me tell you, this place is amazing. I have since been here 5 more times. The food is amazing, the atmosphere is amazing, the service is above and beyond superb! I highly enjoy going here. You will not be disappointed. The menu has a large selection of meals and the prices are fair and the portions are huge. EXCEPTIONAL!!!!!!

I have lived in this area for 30 years and have never been here. I finally went to dinner here and let me tell you, this place is amazing. I have since been here 5 more times. The food is amazing, the atmosphere is amazing, the service is above and beyond superb! I highly enjoy going here. You will not be disappointed. The menu has a large selection of meals and the prices are fair and the portions are huge. EXCEPTIONAL!!!!!!

Been around in Dayton for a long time. Wanted to try the infamous treasure island. Subpar to say the least. 2 hours there total. Valentine’s Day understand busy, but this should have been planned. Food is poor. No flavor. The prices are absurd. I understand inflation but the price tag we are paying for a dinner plate you would expect flavorful dinner

Been around in Dayton for a long time. Wanted to try the infamous treasure island. Subpar to say the least. 2 hours there total. Valentine’s Day understand busy, but this should have been planned. Food is poor. No flavor. The prices are absurd. I understand inflation but the price tag we are paying for a dinner plate you would expect flavorful dinner

What can I say, I was feeling nostalgic after work tonight and decided that I would go to Treasure Island Supper Club. I hadn’t been here for a couple years but prior to that I went once or twice a year. I walked in and the atmosphere was the same. The staff was just as friendly my server Casey was amazing. She was friendly, checked in at all the right times and kept my ice tea full. What wasn’t so great was the food. I came for the prime rib which was always delicious( 39.95 on menu now) What I had tonight was good but not great. In the past it was perfectly seasoned with a delicious crust. It made you make the trip just for the prime. This prime was one that you could get at any chain restaurant: not bad but not great either. The sides were terrible. A bagged salad mix that wasn’t even crisp or very cold. The garlic mashed potatoes with cheese that in the past were creamy and delicious and creamy were hard like warmed up mashed potatoes that sat around too long. I ordered two more sides to replace them. The lyonnaise potatoes were hashbrowns with onions: tasty but not traditional. The vegetables were all overcooked and squishy. Sometimes our memories give us an idea of what we had in the past. This wasn’t the food I knew and loved in the past. It will probably be a long time before I return.

What can I say, I was feeling nostalgic after work tonight and decided that I would go to Treasure Island Supper Club. I hadn’t been here for a couple years but prior to that I went once or twice a year. I walked in and the atmosphere was the same. The staff was just as friendly my server Casey was amazing. She was friendly, checked in at all the right times and kept my ice tea full. What wasn’t so great was the food. I came for the prime rib which was always delicious( 39.95 on menu now) What I had tonight was good but not great. In the past it was perfectly seasoned with a delicious crust. It made you make the trip just for the prime. This prime was one that you could get at any chain restaurant: not bad but not great either. The sides were terrible. A bagged salad mix that wasn’t even crisp or very cold. The garlic mashed potatoes with cheese that in the past were creamy and delicious and creamy were hard like warmed up mashed potatoes that sat around too long. I ordered two more sides to replace them. The lyonnaise potatoes were hashbrowns with onions: tasty but not traditional. The vegetables were all overcooked and squishy. Sometimes our memories give us an idea of what we had in the past. This wasn’t the food I knew and loved in the past. It will probably be a long time before I return.

We were so happy to observe excellent service and excellent food. Nancy came around to say hello and listen to our rave reviews of the old treasure island supper club being back in business! We thoroughly enjoyed our server, the food came out excellent and promptly. The prices are definitely in line with today’s market. Very much worth the time coming here. We will definitely be back regularly. I ordered the filet and my husband ordered the pork chops and dinner did NOT disappoint. Please come and experience Treasure Island Supper Club when you have a chance. YUM!😋

We were so happy to observe excellent service and excellent food. Nancy came around to say hello and listen to our rave reviews of the old treasure island supper club being back in business! We thoroughly enjoyed our server, the food came out excellent and promptly. The prices are definitely in line with today’s market. Very much worth the time coming here. We will definitely be back regularly. I ordered the filet and my husband ordered the pork chops and dinner did NOT disappoint. Please come and experience Treasure Island Supper Club when you have a chance. YUM!😋

I have been coming here since a child with my parents. We dine here numerous times each month. Food and service are always excellent. The house salad dressing is some of the best around. I had scallops last time for supper and they were prepared perfectly. Wife's shrimp was excellent as well. Here today for lunch. Service was attentive prompt and friendly I had Mahi sandwich and wife had onion soup and potatoes skins. Potatoes skins are made in house and delicious. Soup was rich and very good. Mahi was very good - seasoned and cooked perfectly. You might call the atmosphere Old School but it is very charming and comfortable.

I have been coming here since a child with my parents. We dine here numerous times each month. Food and service are always excellent. The house salad dressing is some of the best around. I had scallops last time for supper and they were prepared perfectly. Wife's shrimp was excellent as well. Here today for lunch. Service was attentive prompt and friendly I had Mahi sandwich and wife had onion soup and potatoes skins. Potatoes skins are made in house and delicious. Soup was rich and very good. Mahi was very good - seasoned and cooked perfectly. You might call the atmosphere Old School but it is very charming and comfortable.

The restaurant's atmosphere is very mid-century casino. The decor is awesome. The food is great too. I went with my partner and Aunt. We each loved our meals. I had a fillet with side salad and baked potato. The filet was cooked perfectly! My partner had chicken livers with onions and my aunt has chicken fettuccini with Alfredo. They loved theireals as well!!

The restaurant's atmosphere is very mid-century casino. The decor is awesome. The food is great too. I went with my partner and Aunt. We each loved our meals. I had a fillet with side salad and baked potato. The filet was cooked perfectly! My partner had chicken livers with onions and my aunt has chicken fettuccini with Alfredo. They loved theireals as well!!

Our first time visiting. All 4 of us ordered something different from the others and we were all extremely satisfied with what we got!! Very fresh, hot and tasty. Our service couldn’t have been any better!! We will definitely be back to Treasure Island again!!!

Our first time visiting. All 4 of us ordered something different from the others and we were all extremely satisfied with what we got!! Very fresh, hot and tasty. Our service couldn’t have been any better!! We will definitely be back to Treasure Island again!!!