Back to Columbus
Hickory House Restaurant - Steakhouse in Columbus, Ohio

Hickory House Restaurant

4.4 (2023 reviews)

7051 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Steak house
American restaurant
Barbecue restaurant
Family restaurant
Restaurant

About Hickory House Restaurant - steak house in Columbus, Ohio

Relaxed eatery with a warm atmosphere serving barbecue fare, steaks, burgers & seafood.

Customer Review Summary

Hickory House Restaurant received mixed reviews. Many customers praised the warm, homey atmosphere and festive decorations. The food, particularly dishes like ribs, pulled pork, and French onion soup, was often described as delicious. Several reviewers highlighted exceptional service, particularly from a server named Kelli, who was noted for her genuine and attentive approach. However, there were also significant complaints about food quality and service, particularly regarding a poorly cooked ribeye steak that resulted in food poisoning. Some diners found certain dishes like pork chops to be tough and dry, contrasting with others who raved about the ribs. Overall, while many enjoyed their experience and expressed a desire to return, some left disappointed with their meals and service consistency.

Key Features

Service options

  • Curbside pickup
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Great beer selection
  • Great cocktails
  • Great coffee
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
  • Sports

Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Happy hour drinks
  • Happy hour food
  • Hard liquor
  • Healthy options
  • Vegetarian options
  • Wine

Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Dessert
  • Seating

Amenities

  • Bar onsite
  • Restroom
  • Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy

Crowd

  • Family-friendly
  • Groups
  • Tourists

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments

Children

  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu

Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking

Customer Reviews

Rating Distribution

4.4 out of 5
5
1347
4
404
3
120
2
59
1
93
Based on 2023 reviews

Victoria Barker

3 months ago

Absolutely wonderful! We would eat here again. The restaurant environment is so homey feeling. We loved the Christmas decorations. The haddock, home fries, french fries, coleslaw (sweet), RIBS, pulled pork sandwich, french onion soup, Mac and cheese, and corn nuggets were all incredible! 🤌🏻 They've got these recipes down, and maybe a little salt and pepper here and there. Our server was so sweet and did a great job dealing with all of us!

Elisabeth Wilson

4 weeks ago

I've lived here several years and can't believe i just now heard of it. My dad wanted to go for his 80th birthday. We WILL BE BACK!!! Everyone was super welcoming. Service on POINT. Food was DELICIOUS and the BBQ was out of this world.

Monique Gonzalez

2 months ago

Afternoon lunch experience was perfect. Mark, our server was helpful with menu options because this was out first time eating here. Appetizer, drinks for two and it meals arrived hot and fresh.

Kayli Wynott

1 month ago

Came here on a work trip, food was very bland and service wasnt great for a steakhouse. I got a ribeye, ordered it rare, it was very cold in the middle and it was practically raw with a little bit of blue at the end of the steak. As someone who always orders a rare steak, and has no issues, I ended up with severe food poisoning with vomitting & diaherria. I would not recommend this place to anyone.

Brad

The food was okay. I had the pork chops. They were a bit tough and dry. My mom had the rack of ribs. She said that they were the best ribs she's ever had. The place is fairly expensive for what it is. Our waitress couldn't be bothered with us for the most part until we were almost done with our dinner and then she was super nice. Guess she had to get in for that tip. Well, here's a tip. Try to be super nice the entire time and try to be super helpful the entire time. You still got a good tip. I'm going to tip you good no matter what but the best tip I can give you is is give consistent service. Good consistent service

Jeanette Hall

French onion soup was delicious. Outstanding in fact. I ordered the steak& blue cheese salad. Mouthwatering to say the least. Spouse had steak and fries. Food and service excellent. NOTE: PLEASE pay special attention to the the menu description of how you would like your steak prepared. Not all restaurants follow the same recipe. Hickory House has listed exactly how they categorize rare to well done perfection.

Keith Ngede

Kelli is the best! She made our night and even sang a birthday song for my dad. She’s so genuine and patient, and the Food! Kelli suggested the barbecue ribs and we weren’t disappointed. So so good. We’ll definitely be back. If you’re reading this, please don’t think twice and pay this place a visit!

Monique Mayle

2 months ago

Our server, Kelli, was PHENOMENAL! Recommendations were perfect, from appetizer to drinks, everything was delicious.

Location

Contact Information

Hours of Operation

Friday 11 AM–12 AM
Monday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–12 AM
Sunday 1–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM

Price Range

$20–30