Tony's of Indianapolis

My favorites were the crab cake, the sourdough bread, and the whipped potatoes. His filet was perfect. My steak was thick and tough. I think it was the cut. They had live music and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I would definitely go back to try a few other items.

My favorites were the crab cake, the sourdough bread, and the whipped potatoes. His filet was perfect. My steak was thick and tough. I think it was the cut. They had live music and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I would definitely go back to try a few other items.

A wonderful place for steak! I tried the Jack’s dry Aged New York strip, and it was cooked to perfection. The complimentary dessert for my birthday was a delightful touch. The ambiance inside felt very cozy, and the customer service was excellent.

A wonderful place for steak! I tried the Jack’s dry Aged New York strip, and it was cooked to perfection. The complimentary dessert for my birthday was a delightful touch. The ambiance inside felt very cozy, and the customer service was excellent.

Completely perfect and hits in all areas. Not too many could even compete or come close to the experience you'll get coming here. A decent price for the top quality meal, service, and environment. This made our list of top 10 places we would recommend this one located here Indianapolis to our friends, family and followers. The filet migon has to be the most tender, and flavorful filled steak I have ever tasted - that even could beat out our #1 restaurant St Elmo's Steakhouse. On the downside; I wasn't fond of the grilled Caesar because the heat just didn't taste right and almost counteracted the crispy refreshing taste of the normal. My wife's crisp wedge was refreshing and perfectly made as long as paying $14 for a quarter of a head of lettuce seems reasonable. I would say most restaurants make 10x the actual cost on salads. We both were not fans of the cheap feel of the fried crispy onions on the side our steak. It mitigated the high class filet migon. It almost felt like canned onion crisp and we didn't even eat them. (just a bad cheap touch). My wife's main dish was Crabcake - which she said was the absolute best she ever had. The bar was the biggest stand out experience that was hosted by Jayden as our bartender- she makes the best "Pirate" drinks! Have her make you one! I will definitely return to the bar! We will return to explore the menu more!

Completely perfect and hits in all areas. Not too many could even compete or come close to the experience you'll get coming here. A decent price for the top quality meal, service, and environment. This made our list of top 10 places we would recommend this one located here Indianapolis to our friends, family and followers. The filet migon has to be the most tender, and flavorful filled steak I have ever tasted - that even could beat out our #1 restaurant St Elmo's Steakhouse. On the downside; I wasn't fond of the grilled Caesar because the heat just didn't taste right and almost counteracted the crispy refreshing taste of the normal. My wife's crisp wedge was refreshing and perfectly made as long as paying $14 for a quarter of a head of lettuce seems reasonable. I would say most restaurants make 10x the actual cost on salads. We both were not fans of the cheap feel of the fried crispy onions on the side our steak. It mitigated the high class filet migon. It almost felt like canned onion crisp and we didn't even eat them. (just a bad cheap touch). My wife's main dish was Crabcake - which she said was the absolute best she ever had. The bar was the biggest stand out experience that was hosted by Jayden as our bartender- she makes the best "Pirate" drinks! Have her make you one! I will definitely return to the bar! We will return to explore the menu more!

The service was absolutely impeccable. They refilled water glasses and drinks promptly and immediately cleared dishes and brought out new utensils and plates for the next course. They also offered warm towels to use after eating oysters on the half shell, which my husband said were delicious and fresh. I highly recommend the sausage and peppers appetizer. It's spicy and flavorful. Also try the grilled caesar salad! Our main entrées were the tuna and 9 ounce filet. Both were good. The steak was cooked as I ordered, medium well. We ended the meal with chocolate mousse, which is served with an incredible raspberry sauce and comes in an edible chocolate tea cup that gives major Willy Wonka vibes! Overall, this is a great restaurant to enjoy a nice meal and good service. Valet parking is available or there are several garages nearby. It's conveniently located next to the IRT and Circle Center Mall.

The service was absolutely impeccable. They refilled water glasses and drinks promptly and immediately cleared dishes and brought out new utensils and plates for the next course. They also offered warm towels to use after eating oysters on the half shell, which my husband said were delicious and fresh. I highly recommend the sausage and peppers appetizer. It's spicy and flavorful. Also try the grilled caesar salad! Our main entrées were the tuna and 9 ounce filet. Both were good. The steak was cooked as I ordered, medium well. We ended the meal with chocolate mousse, which is served with an incredible raspberry sauce and comes in an edible chocolate tea cup that gives major Willy Wonka vibes! Overall, this is a great restaurant to enjoy a nice meal and good service. Valet parking is available or there are several garages nearby. It's conveniently located next to the IRT and Circle Center Mall.

We were in Indy for the weekend for my husband’s birthday (visiting from Canada) and it was an unreal experience. Our waiter, Allan, was so so friendly and made recommendations for us that were delicious. We split a 22oz bone-in ribeye and we’re not disappointed. Steak was cooked perfectly, they even cut it and put it on separate plates for us, which we were expecting to do ourselves, the flavours were amazing, we got the garlic butter on top, side of mashed potatoes, and asparagus. Wow. We will absolutely go back to Indy just for Tony’s. Thanks for the great experience!

We were in Indy for the weekend for my husband’s birthday (visiting from Canada) and it was an unreal experience. Our waiter, Allan, was so so friendly and made recommendations for us that were delicious. We split a 22oz bone-in ribeye and we’re not disappointed. Steak was cooked perfectly, they even cut it and put it on separate plates for us, which we were expecting to do ourselves, the flavours were amazing, we got the garlic butter on top, side of mashed potatoes, and asparagus. Wow. We will absolutely go back to Indy just for Tony’s. Thanks for the great experience!

I Had An AMAZING BDAY 🎂 🥳 2Nite. Allan Was An AWESOME Server...Patient, Attentive & Gr8 Suggestions For Our Meals. Food Is DELICIOUS 😋 Drinks Are Well Balanced - My Blueberry🫐 Martini 🍸Was So GOOD 😋 This Is My 1st Time Here...But Certainly Not My Last. THANK YOU ALL For A Very Special Nite🎂🌠

I Had An AMAZING BDAY 🎂 🥳 2Nite. Allan Was An AWESOME Server...Patient, Attentive & Gr8 Suggestions For Our Meals. Food Is DELICIOUS 😋 Drinks Are Well Balanced - My Blueberry🫐 Martini 🍸Was So GOOD 😋 This Is My 1st Time Here...But Certainly Not My Last. THANK YOU ALL For A Very Special Nite🎂🌠

This place had been recommended so many times, however I never had a chance to visit this place. The moment I entered, I was greeted with smile on her face. I told, I have a reservation. They gave me very good table. The ambinace is just amazing. They have a good selection of wines and I had asked for specific one and I had mentioned in my reservation. The steak is just amazing, I tried NY Strip steak, medium rare, it was just perfect. I will surely return.

This place had been recommended so many times, however I never had a chance to visit this place. The moment I entered, I was greeted with smile on her face. I told, I have a reservation. They gave me very good table. The ambinace is just amazing. They have a good selection of wines and I had asked for specific one and I had mentioned in my reservation. The steak is just amazing, I tried NY Strip steak, medium rare, it was just perfect. I will surely return.