Brigantine Seafood & Oyster Bar

OK, so we ate here on a whim. And while it took us a few mins to actually get service, they totally made up for it. The food is delicious and everyone was so nice. The inside is beautiful also. I like that they have a nice and maybe a little more fancy dining area and then a more casual sports bar type area. Definitely recommend. (Do not skip the creme brulee)

OK, so we ate here on a whim. And while it took us a few mins to actually get service, they totally made up for it. The food is delicious and everyone was so nice. The inside is beautiful also. I like that they have a nice and maybe a little more fancy dining area and then a more casual sports bar type area. Definitely recommend. (Do not skip the creme brulee)

Seafood restaurant with plenty of bar seating and tables for happy hour (outside on the second floor has views of the harbor!). Happy hour is 3pm to close on Mondays. We ordered house red wine, spinach salad, calamari, fish sandwich with fries and wagyu burger with fries. All were $7 and very good quality. The burger was tiny so I wouldn't get it again. The service wasn't great (we had to hunt down the waiter 3 times).

Seafood restaurant with plenty of bar seating and tables for happy hour (outside on the second floor has views of the harbor!). Happy hour is 3pm to close on Mondays. We ordered house red wine, spinach salad, calamari, fish sandwich with fries and wagyu burger with fries. All were $7 and very good quality. The burger was tiny so I wouldn't get it again. The service wasn't great (we had to hunt down the waiter 3 times).

Starting from the top the restaurant greeter was more than welcoming. Our waitress started off with great customer service and explained all of the Chef’s specials. My wife got the Prime Rib and I got the fish tacos, Chef does not play when it comes to the food. Overall a great experience and the cocktails were very delicious as well.

Starting from the top the restaurant greeter was more than welcoming. Our waitress started off with great customer service and explained all of the Chef’s specials. My wife got the Prime Rib and I got the fish tacos, Chef does not play when it comes to the food. Overall a great experience and the cocktails were very delicious as well.

When you walk in it smells like a cross between my Grandma’s house when she used moth balls to store her clothes and the ocean. You walk up the stairs and you are greeted by some really nice people. The staff is always great here. I like the ambiance. We enjoy the view of the palm trees in the window from the main dining area or sitting in the bar area or on the deck. The food it pretty good. The oysters rock is good - they use fondue cheese and it doesn’t have that crusted layer of cheese on the top is my only complaint. The surf and turf tacos are really good. They have a little flavor “kick” not overly spicy but a little heat. I forgot to name of the dessert but it was also good. Oreo cookie crust with coffee ice cream- the coffee flavor is mild almost absent - just like I like it. It’s a good option for brunch, lunch or dinner on Shelter Island.

When you walk in it smells like a cross between my Grandma’s house when she used moth balls to store her clothes and the ocean. You walk up the stairs and you are greeted by some really nice people. The staff is always great here. I like the ambiance. We enjoy the view of the palm trees in the window from the main dining area or sitting in the bar area or on the deck. The food it pretty good. The oysters rock is good - they use fondue cheese and it doesn’t have that crusted layer of cheese on the top is my only complaint. The surf and turf tacos are really good. They have a little flavor “kick” not overly spicy but a little heat. I forgot to name of the dessert but it was also good. Oreo cookie crust with coffee ice cream- the coffee flavor is mild almost absent - just like I like it. It’s a good option for brunch, lunch or dinner on Shelter Island.

Was 8pm so I get it a tad late. The gal who brought our menus sighed but then Carlos came to wait on us was so nice and attentive. Tacos were fantastic. Coconut shrimp appetizer comes with this great sauce definitely a must try. Our favorite taco was the swordfish perfectly done

Was 8pm so I get it a tad late. The gal who brought our menus sighed but then Carlos came to wait on us was so nice and attentive. Tacos were fantastic. Coconut shrimp appetizer comes with this great sauce definitely a must try. Our favorite taco was the swordfish perfectly done

Even though sand dabs are on the online luncheon menu they do NOT have sand dabs for lunch. Drove all the way to restaurant to find out they only serve sand dabs for dinner. Online menu should reflect this. Not impressed with food we did order for lunch. Should have had tuna sandwich at home..

Even though sand dabs are on the online luncheon menu they do NOT have sand dabs for lunch. Drove all the way to restaurant to find out they only serve sand dabs for dinner. Online menu should reflect this. Not impressed with food we did order for lunch. Should have had tuna sandwich at home..

I will start by saying great staff!!! My nephew decided to have his wedding rehearsal dinner here and they were very attentive, fast and friendly. There was a separate menu for our party and professionally done. I had the steak and although the steak itself lacked the right amount of seasoning, the elements that topped the steak and the bed of potatoes and sauce that it sat upon balanced it out perfectly (risky, yet well played.) The salmon was cooked just right and the flavors were good but not great. The wagyu burger was perfect and so were the scallops. My old fashioned was stronger than my liking but the Moscow mule was exceptional. Overall, it was a great experience along with a great atmosphere. I will be back.

I will start by saying great staff!!! My nephew decided to have his wedding rehearsal dinner here and they were very attentive, fast and friendly. There was a separate menu for our party and professionally done. I had the steak and although the steak itself lacked the right amount of seasoning, the elements that topped the steak and the bed of potatoes and sauce that it sat upon balanced it out perfectly (risky, yet well played.) The salmon was cooked just right and the flavors were good but not great. The wagyu burger was perfect and so were the scallops. My old fashioned was stronger than my liking but the Moscow mule was exceptional. Overall, it was a great experience along with a great atmosphere. I will be back.