Mastro's City Hall

My wife and I had the absolute pleasure of dining at Mastro’s City Hall Steakhouse, and it was an unforgettable experience! The service was nothing short of impeccable—every staff member went above and beyond to make us feel welcome and cared for. The food? Absolutely decadent. Each dish was crafted to perfection, bursting with flavor, and left us wanting for nothing. The atmosphere was equally delightful—elegant, warm, and inviting. We were blessed to enjoy this meal as a gift from Jerry Seiner Dealerships, and it made the experience all the more special. The staff made every step of our journey easy and worry free. Thank you to the team at Mastro’s for creating such a memorable evening for us. We will definitely be back! Go see Fedja and Gary they will provide for you with an amazing experience through their service ! Thanks again guys !

My wife and I had the absolute pleasure of dining at Mastro’s City Hall Steakhouse, and it was an unforgettable experience! The service was nothing short of impeccable—every staff member went above and beyond to make us feel welcome and cared for. The food? Absolutely decadent. Each dish was crafted to perfection, bursting with flavor, and left us wanting for nothing. The atmosphere was equally delightful—elegant, warm, and inviting. We were blessed to enjoy this meal as a gift from Jerry Seiner Dealerships, and it made the experience all the more special. The staff made every step of our journey easy and worry free. Thank you to the team at Mastro’s for creating such a memorable evening for us. We will definitely be back! Go see Fedja and Gary they will provide for you with an amazing experience through their service ! Thanks again guys !

I chose this restaurant to celebrate my birthday and boy did I feel special. My first time here and this was the best fine dining service experience ever. My sister E planned for our parents to fly in as a surprise and dinner here with my family was the icing on the cake. Our waiter Billy was phenomal. He was personable, friendly, humorous, and kind. The other wait staff, management, and hostesses were awesome in making us feel as valued diners. The restaurant is very clean and well kept. The ambiance is cozy and intimate. Perfect for any type of dinner date. The food was served strategically to ensure everyone's meal came out at the same time. Being served was a delightful experience. The lobster mashed potatoes was the highlight of the sides and the steaks were delicious. The signature butter cake was excellent. Not too sweet, but just right. Served with ice cream and also a side of whipped cream made from scratch. Mouthwatering good. Looking forward to another amazing dining experience soon.

I chose this restaurant to celebrate my birthday and boy did I feel special. My first time here and this was the best fine dining service experience ever. My sister E planned for our parents to fly in as a surprise and dinner here with my family was the icing on the cake. Our waiter Billy was phenomal. He was personable, friendly, humorous, and kind. The other wait staff, management, and hostesses were awesome in making us feel as valued diners. The restaurant is very clean and well kept. The ambiance is cozy and intimate. Perfect for any type of dinner date. The food was served strategically to ensure everyone's meal came out at the same time. Being served was a delightful experience. The lobster mashed potatoes was the highlight of the sides and the steaks were delicious. The signature butter cake was excellent. Not too sweet, but just right. Served with ice cream and also a side of whipped cream made from scratch. Mouthwatering good. Looking forward to another amazing dining experience soon.

Came here right after eating at Uchi on Tuesday evening (3/4/25) because he really wanted steak lol. We shared a steak and dessert. It looked pretty busy for a Tuesday night. Service is always good here. We were seated at a different table in the bar area at first but had asked to be moved to the side with booths instead. Staff were all friendly and accommodating. Our order: Large San Pellegrino $10 Ube cocktail w/ Rum $19 Stoli Dirty Martini x2 $54 Bone In Kansas City Strip $73 Creamed Spinach $16 Butter Cake $19 He asked for the steak to come out sliced so we could share. I was pretty full already so only had a few bites. Think I liked this steak better the last time we were here. It needed to be cooked just a bit longer. Wanted to save room for the delicious butter cake! We killed the dessert and I took home the leftover steak and side. I forgot the name of my ube cocktail. It comes with tequila but I subbed it with rum instead since I don't drink tequila. It was good! Im sure we'll be back again at some point

Came here right after eating at Uchi on Tuesday evening (3/4/25) because he really wanted steak lol. We shared a steak and dessert. It looked pretty busy for a Tuesday night. Service is always good here. We were seated at a different table in the bar area at first but had asked to be moved to the side with booths instead. Staff were all friendly and accommodating. Our order: Large San Pellegrino $10 Ube cocktail w/ Rum $19 Stoli Dirty Martini x2 $54 Bone In Kansas City Strip $73 Creamed Spinach $16 Butter Cake $19 He asked for the steak to come out sliced so we could share. I was pretty full already so only had a few bites. Think I liked this steak better the last time we were here. It needed to be cooked just a bit longer. Wanted to save room for the delicious butter cake! We killed the dessert and I took home the leftover steak and side. I forgot the name of my ube cocktail. It comes with tequila but I subbed it with rum instead since I don't drink tequila. It was good! Im sure we'll be back again at some point

A wonderful establishment for a fine steak. They have a great selection of bourbon, and wine. Our waiter was very attentive and knowledgeable on the menu with exceptional recommendations on both wine and food. The atmosphere can be loud so if you're expecting a quiet dinner this is not the place. Overall great food and service would recommend anyone looking for a well rounded and delightful dinner.

A wonderful establishment for a fine steak. They have a great selection of bourbon, and wine. Our waiter was very attentive and knowledgeable on the menu with exceptional recommendations on both wine and food. The atmosphere can be loud so if you're expecting a quiet dinner this is not the place. Overall great food and service would recommend anyone looking for a well rounded and delightful dinner.

Be very careful when the waiter tells you they have a few off menu items. You better be sure and ask the price now hear me out. I didn’t go there wanting a price budget place but when your steak topping is double of what your fillet is, you got big problems i.e. ordered a fillet $62 ordered the crab meat to go on top 75 when I asked for an explanation, the waiter and the manager disappeared for 30 minutes. All I wanted to do is ask a question I would not recommend this place. The food was just OK lots of Greece and I’ve eaten a lot of top in restaurants. This is not one of them that I would recommend going to it all.

Be very careful when the waiter tells you they have a few off menu items. You better be sure and ask the price now hear me out. I didn’t go there wanting a price budget place but when your steak topping is double of what your fillet is, you got big problems i.e. ordered a fillet $62 ordered the crab meat to go on top 75 when I asked for an explanation, the waiter and the manager disappeared for 30 minutes. All I wanted to do is ask a question I would not recommend this place. The food was just OK lots of Greece and I’ve eaten a lot of top in restaurants. This is not one of them that I would recommend going to it all.

Our experience at Mastro’s City Hall in Scottsdale was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we arrived, the front staff was incredibly accommodating, quickly fitting us in despite our accidental booking at a different location. The ambiance is immaculate, giving off old New York vibes with its dim lighting and beautifully clean setting. Our waiter, Christopher, was absolutely fantastic. His attention to detail and warm demeanor made the evening even more enjoyable. The food, as always, was immaculate. We started with the Fanny Bay oysters and shrimp, both of which were fresh and flavorful. I had the salmon, and my boyfriend ordered the steak—both dishes were cooked to perfection. The portion sizes were generous, especially with the sides of corn and French fries. To top off an already amazing meal, we had the butter cake for dessert, which is a must-try if you’re ever in the area. It’s absolutely divine. The wait staff, including those who cleaned our table between courses, were top-notch, ensuring everything was spotless and timely. If you’re looking for a place with incredible food, outstanding service, and a classic, sophisticated vibe, Mastro’s Ocean Club is the place to be. Don’t forget to order the butter cake—you won’t regret it!

Our experience at Mastro’s City Hall in Scottsdale was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we arrived, the front staff was incredibly accommodating, quickly fitting us in despite our accidental booking at a different location. The ambiance is immaculate, giving off old New York vibes with its dim lighting and beautifully clean setting. Our waiter, Christopher, was absolutely fantastic. His attention to detail and warm demeanor made the evening even more enjoyable. The food, as always, was immaculate. We started with the Fanny Bay oysters and shrimp, both of which were fresh and flavorful. I had the salmon, and my boyfriend ordered the steak—both dishes were cooked to perfection. The portion sizes were generous, especially with the sides of corn and French fries. To top off an already amazing meal, we had the butter cake for dessert, which is a must-try if you’re ever in the area. It’s absolutely divine. The wait staff, including those who cleaned our table between courses, were top-notch, ensuring everything was spotless and timely. If you’re looking for a place with incredible food, outstanding service, and a classic, sophisticated vibe, Mastro’s Ocean Club is the place to be. Don’t forget to order the butter cake—you won’t regret it!

I had such a great dining experience! The food was delicious, and the atmosphere was really nice. Shout out to Carissa (server) she had amazing customer service. She went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect, and her kindness and attentiveness didn’t go unnoticed. She truly made my visit special—thank you, Carissa! I Would recommend, definitely will be going back

I had such a great dining experience! The food was delicious, and the atmosphere was really nice. Shout out to Carissa (server) she had amazing customer service. She went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect, and her kindness and attentiveness didn’t go unnoticed. She truly made my visit special—thank you, Carissa! I Would recommend, definitely will be going back

I had an amazing experience at Mastros with my gf. They accommodated everything we needed and the waiter was fantastic. This is a classic swanky steakhouse with a great location. I chose to valet and that went smoothly as well. I recommend a steak of your choice with a side of bernaise sauce (like a hollandaise) with a bottle of red. The bread basket was super yummy, and we also ordered sushi as an appetizer which was solid and novel. Special recommendation their signature warm butter cake was to die for. Do that with a cappuccino.

I had an amazing experience at Mastros with my gf. They accommodated everything we needed and the waiter was fantastic. This is a classic swanky steakhouse with a great location. I chose to valet and that went smoothly as well. I recommend a steak of your choice with a side of bernaise sauce (like a hollandaise) with a bottle of red. The bread basket was super yummy, and we also ordered sushi as an appetizer which was solid and novel. Special recommendation their signature warm butter cake was to die for. Do that with a cappuccino.