Charlie The Butcher's Carvery

Right down the street from KBUF. Small restaurant. Nice dining area outside. You walk in and order, walk around the corner to pay, and have a seat. The Brunswick stew was worth the trip by itself. It was delicious! The Beef on Weck with the raw horseradish was really good. I'm not typically going to pick a roast beef sandwich, but this roll (the Weck) takes it up another notch! The staff were very nice. I wish I'd gotten another bowl of the stew.

Right down the street from KBUF. Small restaurant. Nice dining area outside. You walk in and order, walk around the corner to pay, and have a seat. The Brunswick stew was worth the trip by itself. It was delicious! The Beef on Weck with the raw horseradish was really good. I'm not typically going to pick a roast beef sandwich, but this roll (the Weck) takes it up another notch! The staff were very nice. I wish I'd gotten another bowl of the stew.

Asked for no pickle and no horse radish....got it anyway, however it ruined my sandwich because it tasted like pickle. The girl working definitely had some attitude going on ! Clearly didn't listen and had no personality at all. She probably shouldn't be in customer service ! Definitely not her thing. I asked her a question, she looked at me like I should already know the answer. As for the food, roast beef really wasn't up to par. [ However it did taste like pickle]

Asked for no pickle and no horse radish....got it anyway, however it ruined my sandwich because it tasted like pickle. The girl working definitely had some attitude going on ! Clearly didn't listen and had no personality at all. She probably shouldn't be in customer service ! Definitely not her thing. I asked her a question, she looked at me like I should already know the answer. As for the food, roast beef really wasn't up to par. [ However it did taste like pickle]

"Charlie The Butcher" in Buffalo is a quintessential mom and pop shop that exudes authenticity and flavor. From the moment you step in, you're greeted with the tantalizing aroma of freshly roasted meats. The ambiance is cozy and welcoming, reminiscent of a bygone era. Their specialty, buffalo, is expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. The attention to detail in every dish is evident, showcasing their dedication to quality. If you're in Buffalo and craving hearty, mouthwatering cuisine, Charlie The Butcher is a must-visit.

"Charlie The Butcher" in Buffalo is a quintessential mom and pop shop that exudes authenticity and flavor. From the moment you step in, you're greeted with the tantalizing aroma of freshly roasted meats. The ambiance is cozy and welcoming, reminiscent of a bygone era. Their specialty, buffalo, is expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. The attention to detail in every dish is evident, showcasing their dedication to quality. If you're in Buffalo and craving hearty, mouthwatering cuisine, Charlie The Butcher is a must-visit.

Took my sister and spouse to Elmwood Avenue Location to treat my sister for her birthday. I ordered a corn beef on rye, the meat was so tough I alerted the manager & she made me a roast beef medium which was also very tough to the point I showed my sister & spouse how I couldn't even pull it apart with my hands - now that's really tough. I threw it out, it was that bad. There was a price difference of $3.00 between the corn beef and roast beef which I was NOT offered a return. My spouse turkey w/mashed potato was okay, she said nothing memorable. My sisters beef sandwich was okay. I also bought a piece of pumpkin pie so I could somewhat fill up, it was dry probably sitting around a while. My bill came to $44.96 for a lunch that was not satisfying OR up to Charlie the Butcher standards! Had it been the quality of the original Charlie's I wouldn't have minded the high priced sandwiches but the quality at this location is awful. While sitting there I then noticed people were buying mainly the turkey, milk shakes, salads and soup so apparently that is where they make their money. The manager knew I was displeased and would not give me eye contact which is another tell. Take your chances at this location and don't be surprised if you are not satisfied.

Took my sister and spouse to Elmwood Avenue Location to treat my sister for her birthday. I ordered a corn beef on rye, the meat was so tough I alerted the manager & she made me a roast beef medium which was also very tough to the point I showed my sister & spouse how I couldn't even pull it apart with my hands - now that's really tough. I threw it out, it was that bad. There was a price difference of $3.00 between the corn beef and roast beef which I was NOT offered a return. My spouse turkey w/mashed potato was okay, she said nothing memorable. My sisters beef sandwich was okay. I also bought a piece of pumpkin pie so I could somewhat fill up, it was dry probably sitting around a while. My bill came to $44.96 for a lunch that was not satisfying OR up to Charlie the Butcher standards! Had it been the quality of the original Charlie's I wouldn't have minded the high priced sandwiches but the quality at this location is awful. While sitting there I then noticed people were buying mainly the turkey, milk shakes, salads and soup so apparently that is where they make their money. The manager knew I was displeased and would not give me eye contact which is another tell. Take your chances at this location and don't be surprised if you are not satisfied.

What an experience at Charlie the Butcher’s original site. Small place full of locals with great service and food. A must visit if in Buffalo NY. Must have the beef on Weck roast beef sandwich amazing. Everything we tried including home made apple pie was fantastic. Charlie was in, he and the staff were very helpful and friendly.

What an experience at Charlie the Butcher’s original site. Small place full of locals with great service and food. A must visit if in Buffalo NY. Must have the beef on Weck roast beef sandwich amazing. Everything we tried including home made apple pie was fantastic. Charlie was in, he and the staff were very helpful and friendly.

This would have been easily a 4.5 to 5 but sadly my beef on wick was cold. Also we decided to eat inside in the winter months. And I don’t think these people believe in having their heater on. It was freezing inside when eating. Overall tho the sandwich was still good. Hopefully they can look into turning the heat on.

This would have been easily a 4.5 to 5 but sadly my beef on wick was cold. Also we decided to eat inside in the winter months. And I don’t think these people believe in having their heater on. It was freezing inside when eating. Overall tho the sandwich was still good. Hopefully they can look into turning the heat on.

My first time at Charlie’s. Sorry but I expected the beef to be more tender. The Weck was very good but the roast beef had a good floor but I could barely chew the beef. Very disappointing. Will continue looking for a good B on W in Buffalo.

My first time at Charlie’s. Sorry but I expected the beef to be more tender. The Weck was very good but the roast beef had a good floor but I could barely chew the beef. Very disappointing. Will continue looking for a good B on W in Buffalo.